
For the last couple of months down by the pier in Santa Monica there’s been a strange and massive construction residing in the parking lot. This giant iron and canvas colossus built out of shipping containers is the “Nomadic Museum,” and it houses the travelling art show
Ashes and Snow.
The exhibit inside is the work of artist Gregory Colbert, and consists of large sepia-toned photographs, as well as non-narrative short films depicting elephants, whales, birds of prey, and other animals in the presence of meditating, dancing and sleeping humans. The imagery is undeniably beautiful and soothingly mysterious. In one film a man dives deep underwater beneath a swimming elephant, cheetahs move in slow motion amongst blowing sands on a desert dune, and a woman dances as a huge bird of prey swoops overhead. It's visual poetry drenched in sepia, and after a while I found myself succumbing to the meditative state that the entire exhibit exudes.

There are no captions on the photos and only sparse poetic narration in one of the films. Viewers are left to draw their own conclusions as to what this all means. It seems a show of contrasts and similarities. There’s the innocence of a small child curled up against the coarse skin of a towering elephant, or a woman being lead by the hand by an orangutan. In another film, a woman dances writhely amongst a group of baby elephants in latte-thick water. Drenched in monochromatic sepia and shot in slow motion, these are gorgeous images, some heart-achingly beautiful. On the
Ashes and Snow web site the still photos are described as “exploring the poetic sensibilities of animals in their natural habitat as they interact with human beings.”

But as I wandered through this church-like space, along with the appreciation of intent, the depictions of inter-species communion, I also had troubling thoughts. Some of the images seemed to me unintentionally menacing. I was reminded of
Grizzly Man and Timothy Treadwell’s blind and misguided trust in the presence of brute indifference. Are these towering and majestic creatures really exercising their “poetic sensibilities”, or is the mild curiosity on the animals’ part more a tolerance born out of boredom?

There also seemed an element of grasping for connection that bordered on forced communion. I saw this more and more in images of bodies strewn languidly amongst hulking indifference. I’m all for communing with nature and finding the connections between this planets’ beings, but parts of the show seemed exploitative and irresponsible.
The day I was there the exhibit was packed. Hundreds of people, lots of them families with kids in tow, made their way through the space. I wondered what others were thinking of it all. I heard one woman describe the animals as “cute” - I’m not sure this is what the artist was going for.

It’s a subtle and tricky thing to depict a spiritual connection. There’s a danger of slipping into either condescension, or missing the boat entirely and becoming new age art for the masses. In images of a boy drifting on a raft amongst elephants in a stream, I couldn’t help but wonder, are we sailing with Ganesh, or merely adrift? As people sleep next to animals, is it meditative or somnambulant? Is
Ashes and Snow beauty for beauty's sake, or is it all just Gaia-porn?

Near the end of one of the films came the highlight of the entire show. In beautiful underwater photography, a man and a woman swim together in a deep slow-motion dance. There was no forced connection. No grasping for affinity. The images were primal, elemental and beautiful. Maybe it has to do with conscious intent, but all my reservations about the previous images melted away in this one sequence. It reminded me of the grace and beauty in Mary Zimmerman's amazing play
Metamorphosis. It was gorgeous.
So, I have mixed feelings about this show. Some of the images will stay with me for ages, but for some reason I was prevented from fully diving in. I am glad it’s out there to be experienced, but after nearly four hours with all that sepia, I was seriously anticipating the joy of seeing blue again.
Check out the "enhanced experience"
Ashes and Snow web site
here